2016 Standings
 SchoolMSFAOverallGBHomeAwayNeutralStreak
15Robert Morris (IL)5-01.0007-4.636--4-13-30-0Lost 1
 Saint Xavier3-2.6005-6.4552.03-22-40-0Lost 1
 Saint Francis (IL)2-3.4005-6.4553.02-33-30-0Won 1
 Saint Ambrose2-3.4004-6.4003.02-32-30-0Lost 3
 Olivet Nazarene2-3.4004-7.3643.02-32-40-0Lost 1
 Trinity International1-4.2004-7.3644.03-21-50-0Won 3
*Does not qualify for the league championship